Translated from the Portuguese original. Read the original (Português)
When someone learns that the spoken word “cat” matches the picture of a cat and, later, that “cat” matches the written word CAT, something remarkable usually happens: the person starts relating the picture to the written word — without ever having been taught to. Relations that show up this way, as a bonus, are called emergent (or derived) relations; when the stimuli in a set come to function as interchangeable, we say an equivalence class has formed. It is one of the most important findings in behavior analysis, because it helps explain how language grows far beyond what was directly trained — and makes it possible to teach less so the learner learns more.
Emergent (or derived) relations are relations between stimuli that the learner comes to show without direct training or specific reinforcement, as a byproduct of teaching other relations. We speak of stimulus equivalence when the relations among the members of a set satisfy the properties that define an equivalence relation — reflexivity, symmetry, and transitivity — verified by dedicated tests after training on conditional discriminations (Sidman & Tailby, 1982). The stimuli in the same class become mutually substitutable: they control similar responses and can share functions acquired by any one of them.
The finding: I taught two relations, others showed up
The basic procedure is simpler than its name suggests. It is called matching to sample (matching-to-sample, or MTS): a sample is presented — for example, the spoken word “cat” — followed by two or more choice options (the comparisons). Choosing the correct option in the presence of that sample is reinforced; choosing another is not. Since being correct depends on which sample appeared, what is being taught is a conditional discrimination: the correct response is conditional on the context. Each relation taught this way forms the baseline of the training.
In 1971, Murray Sidman described a study that became a landmark in the field. A young man with an intellectual disability could already do two things: name pictures and choose the picture matching a dictated word. What he could not do was read printed words with comprehension. Sidman then taught just one new relation — choosing the printed word matching the dictated word. When tested afterward, the young man related pictures and printed words to each other, in both directions, even though nobody had taught that combination. Reading comprehension had emerged as a side effect of the training.
The four tests that apply
It is not enough to observe that “something new showed up.” To claim that an equivalence class has formed, Sidman and Tailby (1982) showed that you need to test for it — and test without reinforcement, so the test doesn't turn into training in disguise. Three properties define an equivalence relation; the fourth card is the test that checks two of them at once. Tap to see:
Why borrow words from mathematics? Because the idea of “being equivalent” already had a precise definition: in mathematics, a relation is an equivalence relation if it is reflexive, symmetric, and transitive. Sidman and Tailby proposed bringing that same rigor into the laboratory — instead of assuming the learner “understood the meaning,” you define exactly which tests they need to pass. It is the opposite of guessing what is going on inside someone's head.
Teaching less to learn more
Here is why teachers and therapists care about this topic. Imagine a class with three stimuli (A, B, and C). Among them there are six possible directional relations: A→B, B→A, A→C, C→A, B→C, and C→B. If you teach only two of them (A→B and A→C), the other four can emerge: two through symmetry (B→A and C→A) and two through the combined test (B→C and C→B).
- Taught: 2 relations, with reinforcement, until the learner responds consistently correctly.
- Tested (without reinforcement): 4 new relations, which showed up “for free.”
- Result: a class of three interchangeable stimuli — and the effect grows quickly as more members are added.
This reasoning gave rise to what is now called equivalence-based instruction (EBI): planning which few relations to teach so that many others emerge. A meta-analysis by Brodsky and Fienup (2018) gathered EBI studies in higher education, across varied academic content, and concluded that the approach is effective for producing this kind of learning. In Brazil, the best-known case is literacy instruction: the reading and writing program developed by Julio de Rose, Deisy de Souza, and collaborators at UFSCar (the Federal University of São Carlos, in Brazil) combines the equivalence paradigm with learning by exclusion and the task of building the word with movable letters — which helped non-reading children also read new words that were never taught in the program.
Where this shows up in practiceLiteracy and reading comprehension; teaching that ½, 0.5, and 50% are the same quantity; relating spoken word, picture, written word, and sign in augmentative and alternative communication; second-language vocabulary; and teaching complex academic content. In all these cases, the goal is not memorizing pairs — it is forming classes, so the learner can handle combinations the lesson never covered.
Three important implications
Equivalence is not just a laboratory curiosity: it has clinical and theoretical consequences. Explore each one:
What one member gains, the others inherit
Members of the same class don't just share the “correct choice”: they share functions. If one stimulus in the class comes to elicit fear, to be reinforcing, or to signal danger, the others tend to acquire that role without ever going through the experience themselves. In a classic experiment, Dougher and colleagues (1994) formed two classes of four members each and then paired just one member of one class with an aversive stimulus. Measured by skin conductance, the conditioned response also appeared in the presence of the other members of that class, for most participants.
This is why a word, a name, or a memory can trigger intense reactions without ever having been directly paired with anything bad — a mechanism useful for understanding anxiety, avoidance, and the power of what we say to ourselves.
Relations that aren't about “sameness”
Equivalence deals with one specific relation: that of being the same as. But human language relates things in many other ways — bigger than, opposite of, different from, before, better than. Relational Frame Theory (RFT, Hayes, Barnes-Holmes, and Roche, 2001) proposes treating this relational responding as a generalized operant: something learned through many exemplars over a lifetime and then applied to arbitrary stimuli, including relations other than sameness.
RFT is the theoretical foundation of Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) and connects directly with the study of verbal behavior and rule-governed behavior.
Emergence is not magic, nor a guarantee
Emergent relations are a likely outcome under certain conditions — not an automatic one. They often show up only after repeated testing (a phenomenon described as delayed emergence), and some learners — especially young children or those with developmental delays — may not show symmetry or equivalence on a first assessment.
When that happens, the way forward is not to keep testing: it is to teach. The usual path is multiple-exemplar training — practicing the relation in both directions with several different sets of stimuli, until the derived responding generalizes to new sets. In other words, the ability to derive relations can also be built.
Watch out for the shortcut“Emerging without direct teaching” does not mean “without any teaching.” The baseline needs to be well established, the tests need to be done without reinforcement (otherwise you would be training, not testing), and the results need to be measured learner by learner. No serious program promises that a child will “learn on their own” from just two lessons — what the research shows is how to plan instruction to make the most of what the learner can derive.
Test your understanding
Quick quiz
Three questions to lock in the concept. You'll see the explanation right away.
Further reading
- Sidman, M. “Reading and auditory-visual equivalences”. Journal of Speech and Hearing Research, 14, 5–13, 1971.
- Sidman, M.; Tailby, W. “Conditional discrimination vs. matching to sample: an expansion of the testing paradigm”. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 37, 5–22, 1982.
- Sidman, M. “Equivalence relations and behavior: an introductory tutorial”. The Analysis of Verbal Behavior, 25, 5–17, 2009.
- Cooper, J. O.; Heron, T. E.; Heward, W. L. Applied Behavior Analysis. 3rd ed. Pearson, 2020 — chap. 19, “Equivalence-based Instruction” (Carol Pilgrim), and chap. 20, on nonequivalence relations.
- de Rose, J. C.; de Souza, D. G.; Hanna, E. S. “Teaching reading and spelling: exclusion and stimulus equivalence”. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 29, 451–469, 1996.
- Brodsky, J.; Fienup, D. M. “Sidman Goes to College: a meta-analysis of equivalence-based instruction in higher education”. Perspectives on Behavior Science, 41, 95–119, 2018.
- Dougher, M. J.; Augustson, E.; Markham, M. R.; Greenway, D. E.; Wulfert, E. “The transfer of respondent eliciting and extinction functions through stimulus equivalence classes”. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 62, 331–351, 1994.
- Hayes, S. C.; Barnes-Holmes, D.; Roche, B. (eds.). Relational Frame Theory: a Post-Skinnerian Account of Human Language and Cognition. Plenum Press, 2001.
This entry is educational and does not replace assessment, diagnosis or treatment by a qualified health professional. Every person is unique — for a specific case, seek individual guidance.