Translated from the Portuguese original. Read the original (Português)
Rule-governed behavior is behavior controlled by a verbal description of the contingency: an instruction, a piece of advice, a package insert, an agreement — or a rule the person formulates for themselves. It's what lets you get it right the first time without having to make a mistake: “don’t touch it, it’s hot” spares you the burn. On the other side is contingency-shaped behavior, learned through practice, consequence by consequence. The two coexist all the time — but rules have a well-known cost: they can make behavior less sensitive to changes in the real world.
B. F. Skinner distinguished two modes of control over operant behavior: contingency-shaped behavior, acquired through direct and repeated exposure to consequences, and rule-governed behavior, under the control of a contingency-specifying stimulus — a verbal statement that describes, even if incompletely, the relation between antecedent, response, and consequence. In Applied Behavior Analysis (Cooper, Heron & Heward), a rule is defined as the verbal statement of a contingency, and it is what allows behavior to come under indirect control of remote or improbable consequences — consequences that, on their own, would arrive too late — or might never arrive at all — to control what one does right now.
Two ways to reach the same behavior
Imagine two people in front of a stuck door. The first one pushes, pulls, turns the handle, tries again — and after several attempts discovers what works. The second one hears “pull the latch to unlock it” and opens it on the first try. The final behavior looks similar; the history that produced it is completely different.
This difference isn't a theoretical detail. Contingency-shaped behavior tends to be finely tuned and hard to put into words — someone who has ridden a bike for years can rarely describe what they do. Rule-governed behavior shows up fast, but tends to follow the shape of the statement, with all the imprecision it may carry.
Why rules are so useful
Without rules, each person would have to rediscover everything from scratch. With them, the human species can:
- Learn without paying the price of the mistake. “Don’t put your hand in the socket” does away with the shock as teacher.
- Reach distant consequences. Brushing your teeth today produces no noticeable effect on the health of your teeth; the rule is what connects today's action to a result that only shows up years later.
- Make use of what others have already discovered. Manuals, recipes, protocols, and advice pass on contingencies that took generations to map out.
- Coordinate people. Household agreements, traffic laws, and clinical protocols align the behavior of many people at the same time.
- Guide oneself. Saying “first I’ll gather the materials, then I’ll start” is formulating a self-rule — and that's how a good deal of planning works.
A rule isn't an orderIn behavior analysis, “rule” doesn't mean imposition or obedience. The rule is a verbal stimulus, and following rules is, itself, a learned behavior: only someone with a history of being reinforced for doing so follows instructions. That's why it makes no sense to demand rule-following from someone who hasn't yet built that repertoire — it has to be taught.
Three ways to follow a rule
Two people can carry out the same instruction for completely different reasons. Zettle and Hayes (1982) proposed distinguishing types of rule-following by the source of the reinforcement that maintains them. Tap the cards:
The hard part: a rule can make behavior rigid
If the rule accurately describes the world, following it is great. The problem shows up when the world changes and the rule doesn't. In laboratory studies with humans, it's common to observe that people who were given instructions on how to respond keep responding the instructed way even after the programmed consequences have changed — while people who learned without instruction, through direct contact alone, adjust their performance faster. This finding, replicated across different experimental preparations, is described as reduced sensitivity to contingencies.
In everyday life, this has a familiar name: it's the person who insists on a procedure “because that’s how it’s always been done,” the service that keeps a protocol that no longer solves anything, the child who learned “don’t talk to strangers” and doesn't ask a staff member for help when lost. The rule that used to protect has started getting in the way.
Beware of overly rigid rulesVery generic and absolute rules — “I have to handle everything on my own”, “I can’t make mistakes” — tend to describe the real contingencies poorly and resist correction, because whoever follows them rarely gets to test what would happen if they didn't. The way out isn't to abolish rules: it's to go back to looking at what actually happens and reformulate them when they no longer serve.
In practice: school, the clinic, and daily life
The concept changes concrete decisions in each context. Pick a tab:
Instruction only works with someone who already follows instructions
Saying “put your toys away” doesn't teach anything to someone who doesn't yet have instructional control — that is, who hasn't yet learned to behave under verbal guidance. With these learners, the way forward is contingency-shaped teaching: prompts, shaping through successive approximations, and reinforcement of what actually happens — and, in parallel, building instruction-following as a skill to be taught, not assumed.
When instruction already works, it speeds up teaching a great deal. It's worth checking two things: whether the rule really describes the contingency in effect, and whether the learner actually comes into contact with the announced consequence — otherwise the rule becomes empty.
A good deal of suffering runs through rules
Much of what shows up in therapy has the shape of a rule: “if I feel anxious, I need to run away”, “I can only rest once everything is perfect”. These are statements the person follows without testing, and that's why they stay standing even when they cause harm.
Approaches like Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) and CBT work exactly there: helping the person notice the rule as a rule, experience what happens when they act differently, and choose their direction based on what matters to them, rather than on other people's approval.
Protocols help — until they stop describing reality
Checklists, scripts, and agreements exist because they reduce error and save learning time. The risk is turning them into an automatic response: when the scenario changes, someone who just follows the script keeps making the same mistake with precision.
A simple practice helps: reviewing rules with data. Do they still produce the result they promised? If not, rewrite them. It's the same principle behind evidence-based practice applied to the rules that guide everyday life.
How this connects to the rest of behavior analysis
A rule is verbal behavior that comes to function as an antecedent for another person's behavior — or for the speaker's own. It describes a three-term contingency without replacing it: what the rule does is verbally anticipate a relation that, in the end, keeps being tested by the environment. Authors such as Schlinger and Blakely (1987) argue that the statement doesn't act as a simple momentary cue, but rather by altering the function of stimuli and responses — which helps explain why a statement can keep affecting behavior long after it was heard.
Test your understanding
Quick quiz
Three questions to lock in the concept. You'll see the explanation right away.
Further reading
- Skinner, B. F. Contingencies of Reinforcement: A Theoretical Analysis. Appleton-Century-Crofts, 1969 — includes the essay “An Operant Analysis of Problem Solving,” where the distinction between contingency-shaped and rule-governed behavior is presented.
- Hayes, S. C. (ed.). Rule-Governed Behavior: Cognition, Contingencies, and Instructional Control. Plenum Press, 1989.
- Zettle, R. D.; Hayes, S. C. “Rule-Governed Behavior: A Potential Theoretical Framework for Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy”. In: Kendall, P. C. (ed.), Advances in Cognitive-Behavioral Research and Therapy, v. 1. Academic Press, 1982.
- Hayes, S. C.; Brownstein, A. J.; Zettle, R. D.; Rosenfarb, I.; Korn, Z. “Rule-governed behavior and sensitivity to changing consequences of responding”. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 1986.
- Schlinger, H.; Blakely, E. “Function-altering effects of contingency-specifying stimuli”. The Behavior Analyst, 1987.
- Cooper, J. O.; Heron, T. E.; Heward, W. L. Applied Behavior Analysis. 3rd ed., Pearson, 2020.
This entry is educational and does not replace assessment, diagnosis or treatment by a qualified health professional. Every person is unique — for a specific case, seek individual guidance.