Translated from the Portuguese original. Read the original (Português)
A verbal operant is a functional unit of language: it is not defined by the word spoken, but by what evokes it and what maintains it. The same word “ball” can be a mand (the child wants the ball), a tact (she sees the ball and comments on it), or an intraverbal (she answers a question about a ball). Because each is controlled by its own causes, learning one does not guarantee the others — and each function usually needs its own teaching.
In B. F. Skinner’s analysis (Verbal Behavior, 1957), a verbal operant is the minimal unit of analysis of verbal behavior: a class of responses defined by the relation between an antecedent — a motivating operation (a term coined later, by Jack Michael) or a discriminative stimulus —, the speaker’s response, and the consequence that maintains it, delivered through the mediation of a listener. The mand is controlled by a motivating operation and specifies its own reinforcer. The tact is controlled by a nonverbal stimulus present in the environment and maintained by generalized conditioned reinforcement (attention, approval). The intraverbal is controlled by a verbal stimulus with which the response has no point-to-point correspondence, and is also maintained by generalized reinforcement.
Two questions solve almost everything
To figure out which operant is at play, looking at the word itself will not help. You need to look at both sides of it — as in the three-term contingency:
- What came before? Did the person want something? Did she see, hear, or feel something? Or did someone speak to her?
- What came after? Did she receive exactly what she said? Or did she get a social response — attention, a “that’s right!”, the conversation moving on?
With these two answers in hand, the classification almost makes itself. Follow the path of the same word:
The three everyday operants
Skinner described several verbal operants, but three carry the weight of everyday communication — and they are the ones most worked on in the clinic and at school. Explore what controls each one and how it is usually taught:
Mand — asking, refusing, requesting
Before: a motivating operation — hunger, thirst, wanting to play, discomfort, curiosity. After: the person receives exactly what she specified.
Why it comes first: it is the only operant that directly benefits the speaker. Someone who asks and is given what she asked for discovers, in practice, that speaking works — which is why communication programs usually start here.
How it is taught: by taking advantage of moments when motivation already exists (the toy in sight but out of reach, the snack in a sealed package), offering the minimum help needed for the response to happen, and delivering the requested item — not generic praise.
And note: “no,” “stop,” “all done,” and “help me” are mands too. Refusing is communicating.
Tact — naming and commenting
Before: something nonverbal that the person perceives — an object, an action, a smell, a sensation in her own body. After: a social response: attention, confirmation, someone looking along with her.
What it is for: it is the basis of commenting, describing, recounting what happened, and sharing what is perceived. Without tacts, language stays limited to requests.
How it is taught: by presenting the stimulus and transferring control from a prompt (for example, the adult models the word) to the object itself, with social reinforcement. One important caution: if the item happens to be exactly what the person wants at that moment, what is being taught can turn into a disguised mand.
Intraverbal — answering and conversing
Before: another person’s speech (or her own), without the response copying it. After: a social response — the conversation continues.
Examples: “What’s your name?” → “Peter”; “one, two…” → “three”; “what did you do at school?” → an account of it. It is the operant of conversation, of questions, and of memories spoken aloud.
How it is taught: it is the most complex of the three, because the subject of the conversation is usually not present. It tends to be built on an already solid repertoire of tacts, starting with highly familiar sequences (songs, counting, fill-in-the-blank) and moving on to open-ended questions.
Why each one needs its own teaching
Here is the most important — and most counterintuitive — practical consequence of this analysis. Since each of the three is controlled by a different antecedent — and the mand, in addition, by its own consequence — they are relatively independent: mastering one does not guarantee the others, even when the word is exactly the same.
A classic study by Lamarre and Holland (1985) showed this clearly. Preschool children were taught to use the expressions “to the left” and “to the right” — some as a mand (asking where the experimenter should place an object), others as a tact (naming where the object was). In the tests that followed, those who learned to ask did not go on to name, and those who learned to name did not go on to ask. Same words, independent acquisitions.
In practice, this means transfer cannot be assumed. If a child easily asks for a cracker, it is still necessary to check — and probably teach — whether she names a cracker in a picture and answers “what do you eat for a snack?”. After that, it is worth deliberately working on generalization across functions and across contexts.
How this becomes assessmentPrecisely because the operants do not move together, the instruments used in language programs assess each one separately. The VB-MAPP (Sundberg, 2008) and the ABLLS-R (Partington) map mand, tact, echoic, and intraverbal milestones in separate areas — which reveals uneven profiles (many mands and few intraverbals, for example) that a simple count of “how many words the child says” would never show. See ABA and data collection.
In real life, control is almost never pure
The flowchart above is a lens for analysis, not a faithful portrait of conversation. Michael, Palmer, and Sundberg (2011) argue that multiple control — a verbal response under the effect of more than one variable at the same time — is the rule, not the exception. They distinguish two cases:
- Convergent multiple control: several variables acting on one and the same response. This is the case of the child who says “cookie” while seeing the cookie and being hungry — the so-called impure tact, or mand-tact.
- Divergent multiple control: one variable strengthening several different responses. Seeing a dog can evoke “dog,” “woof woof,” the neighbor’s dog’s name, or “I’m scared.”
This has a direct effect on teaching. If a “tact” is always trained with the item the person wants nearby, the response may be being maintained by the item itself — and disappear on the day motivation is not there. That is why tacts are also taught with neutral stimuli and social reinforcement, and the response is tested in situations where there is nothing to gain beyond the conversation.
Test your eye: tap the cards and see which operant is at play in each scene.
How it is taught: transferring control
No one teaches an operant by “explaining” the rule. The standard procedure is transfer of stimulus control: a prompt that already controls that response is presented together with the target stimulus — and then that prompt is withdrawn little by little, until only the target stimulus remains.
- Echoic prompt: the adult says the word and the person repeats it. It is the most common bridge for installing the first mand or the first tact.
- Tact prompt: showing the object while asking the question, then withdrawing it and leaving only the question — the classic path from tact to intraverbal.
- Textual prompt: the written word, for someone who already reads.
In every case, the caution is the same: the prompt needs to be faded in a planned way. A prompt that stays indefinitely produces prompt dependence — the person responds to the adult, not to the situation. And because the right response for the wrong reason is indistinguishable to the naked eye, progress is tracked through data collection, not impression.
Two cautions that are not a minor detailModality matters less than function. A mand can be a word, a sign, a PECS picture, or a tap on an augmentative and alternative communication device — and none of that delays speech. And the goal is power, not performance. Teaching verbal operants serves to expand a person’s capacity to influence her own world — which includes honoring refusal mands and not turning every interaction into a teaching attempt. See ethics and assent.
Test your understanding
Quick quiz
Three questions to lock in the concept. You'll see the explanation right away.
Further reading
- Skinner, B. F. Verbal Behavior. Appleton-Century-Crofts, 1957.
- Cooper, J. O.; Heron, T. E.; Heward, W. L. Applied Behavior Analysis. 3rd ed., Pearson, 2020 — chapter on verbal behavior.
- Lamarre, J.; Holland, J. G. “The functional independence of mands and tacts”. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 1985, 43, 5–19.
- Michael, J.; Palmer, D. C.; Sundberg, M. L. “The multiple control of verbal behavior”. The Analysis of Verbal Behavior, 2011, 27, 3–22.
- Sundberg, M. L.; Michael, J. “The benefits of Skinner’s analysis of verbal behavior for children with autism”. Behavior Modification, 2001, 25, 698–724.
- Sundberg, M. L. VB-MAPP: Verbal Behavior Milestones Assessment and Placement Program. AVB Press, 2008.
This entry is educational and does not replace assessment, diagnosis or treatment by a qualified health professional. Every person is unique — for a specific case, seek individual guidance.