Translated from the Portuguese original. Read the original (Português)
Preference assessment is a set of procedures for systematically identifying which items and activities a person prefers — and how much they prefer each one. It serves to find good reinforcer candidates before starting teaching or an intervention. It can be done by asking (interviews), observing (free access to items), or testing (choices in organized trials). A detail many people confuse: a preferred item is an informed bet, not a confirmed reinforcer — only a contingency test shows that.
In Applied Behavior Analysis, preference assessment (stimulus preference assessment) refers to the procedures used to identify which stimuli a person prefers, the relative value of those stimuli (high, medium, or low preference), the conditions under which that value changes — for example, when task demand or the reinforcement schedule changes — and how much effort the person is willing to make to gain access to them. The product of the assessment is a preference hierarchy: an ordered list of reinforcer candidates (Cooper, Heron & Heward).
Why asking "what does he like?" isn't enough
The question is a good start, but a fragile one. In a classic study, Green and colleagues (1988) compared the opinions of staff who cared for seven people with profound disabilities with a systematic preference assessment based on each person's approach responses to the items. The two methods did not match: what staff assumed to be preferred did not correspond to what the systematic assessment identified. And in a second experiment with five participants, the stimuli identified as preferred by the systematic assessment typically functioned as reinforcers when delivered contingently in skill-training programs.
This does not mean parents, teachers, and caregivers are "wrong" — they know the person and are the best source for putting together the initial list of candidates. What the study shows is that this list needs to be checked with the person, not assumed to be true.
Preference is not a reinforcer
Saying an item is "preferred" describes a choice. Saying it is a reinforcer is a much stronger claim: it means that, delivered right after a behavior, it increases the frequency of that behavior. Preference assessment identifies candidates; what confirms them is reinforcer assessment — a test in which the item is delivered contingently and its effect is observed in the data. See positive reinforcement.
Three paths: asking, observing, testing
There is no single "best" method. The choice depends on how much time is available, how the person communicates, and how precise the answer needs to be. Tap the tabs to learn about each path:
Indirect methods: interviews and questionnaires
You talk with the person themselves (whenever possible) and with those who live with them. A widely used instrument is the RAISD (Reinforcer Assessment for Individuals with Severe Disabilities, by Fisher, Piazza, Bowman & Amari, 1996): a structured interview that goes category by category, asking for concrete details: tactile, auditory, visual, and olfactory items, edibles, and social stimuli.
- Strength: it is quick, requires no materials, and produces a rich list of candidates that no outsider would have imagined.
- Limit: it depends on the memory and interpretation of whoever answers; it serves to generate the list, not to rank it.
Free-operant observation
A set of items is spread out and the person has free, non-contingent access to all of them: nothing is requested, nothing is taken away. The duration of engagement with each item is recorded. Roane and colleagues (1998) evaluated a brief version of this format, with five-minute sessions in which items were never removed, and were able to identify differentially preferred items.
- Strength: it is the most comfortable format — there is no forced choice, no items taken out of the person's hands, no waiting. A good option for those who react poorly to demands.
- Limit: the person may get stuck on the first item they picked up, and items that depend on another person — attention, joint play — may end up underrepresented.
Structured choice trials
Items are presented in organized trials, and what the person selects or approaches is recorded. The proportion of choices generates the hierarchy. This is the family that produces the most detailed ranking — and the one that requires the most time and preparation. The four classic formats appear in the cards below.
- Strength: it produces a clear, comparable ranking, useful for planning instruction and for tracking changes over time.
- Limit: it involves taking items away and waiting between trials, which can be uncomfortable, and requires that the person be able to choose between options.
The four trial formats
Tap the cards to see how each format works and what the research has shown about it:
Why MSWO is so practicalDeLeon and Iwata (1996) compared the three presentation formats — paired choice, multiple with replacement, and multiple without replacement — with seven participants. MSWO produced moderate to high rank-order correlations with paired choice and identified a similar number of reinforcers, but took less than half the administration time. In addition, some stimuli chosen in the paired and MSWO formats — but ignored in the with-replacement format — functioned as reinforcers in subsequent tests.
Preference is a snapshot, not a final portrait
This is the point most often missed in day-to-day practice: the result of a preference assessment holds for that moment. Preference is a largely transitory phenomenon, and research on stability indicates that high-preference items tend to remain more stable, but choices can vary even between successive applications of the MSWO (Melanson and colleagues, 2023). Hence the practical recommendation to reassess frequently — a brief MSWO application before each session, for example, avoids the trap of insisting on an item that has already lost its appeal.
There are two different reasons preference can change, and it's worth telling them apart:
- Momentary change. The child who just had juice no longer wants juice. This is a motivating operation at work: deprivation and satiation alter the value of a reinforcer right now, minute by minute.
- Lasting change. Interests develop, ages pass, repertoires grow. The toy that was the favorite six months ago may simply have been outgrown.
That is why preference assessment is not a step to be "completed" at the start of a plan: it is a recurring practice, integrated into data recording and collection.
How to do it well — and what to avoid
- Vary the categories. Edibles are convenient and satiate quickly. Also include toys, activities, music, videos, sensory materials, and — above all — social interactions: tickles, singing together, praise, chase games.
- Choose the format based on the person, not out of habit. Someone who gets upset when an item is taken away tends to do better with free operant. Someone who chooses well among options benefits more from MSWO.
- Use the right measure. For items that are picked up and put down, selection is counted. For items of continuous engagement — a tablet, a puzzle — the informative measure is the duration of involvement.
- Close the loop with a test. After the hierarchy, check in the data whether the item actually increases the behavior. Without this step, you have a preference, not a reinforcer.
- Treat choice as voice. Offering real options is a concrete way to respect the autonomy of someone who does not yet speak or speaks little, and it underpins work based on assent.
Non-negotiable precautionsThe assessment exists to serve the person, not the procedure. Do not include unsafe or contraindicated items, do not turn the session into a long sequence of items taken out of the person's hands, and stop if the person shows discomfort — signs of discomfort are data, not an obstacle. Identifying an item as preferred also does not authorize using it as a bargaining chip to deprive the person of something they are entitled to.
Test your understanding
Quick quiz
Three questions to reinforce the concept. You'll see the explanation right away.
Further reading
- Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E. & Heward, W. L. Applied Behavior Analysis. 3rd ed. Pearson, 2020 — chapter on positive reinforcement and preference assessment.
- Green, C. W., Reid, D. H., White, L. K., Halford, R. C., Brittain, D. P. & Gardner, S. M. “Identifying reinforcers for persons with profound handicaps: staff opinion versus systematic assessment of preferences”. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 21(1), 31–43, 1988.
- Pace, G. M., Ivancic, M. T., Edwards, G. L., Iwata, B. A. & Page, T. J. “Assessment of stimulus preference and reinforcer value with profoundly retarded individuals”. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 18(3), 249–255, 1985.
- Fisher, W., Piazza, C. C., Bowman, L. G., Hagopian, L. P., Owens, J. C. & Slevin, I. “A comparison of two approaches for identifying reinforcers for persons with severe and profound disabilities”. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 25(2), 491–498, 1992.
- DeLeon, I. G. & Iwata, B. A. “Evaluation of a multiple-stimulus presentation format for assessing reinforcer preferences”. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 29(4), 519–533, 1996.
- Roane, H. S., Vollmer, T. R., Ringdahl, J. E. & Marcus, B. A. “Evaluation of a brief stimulus preference assessment”. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 31(4), 605–620, 1998.
- Fisher, W. W., Piazza, C. C., Bowman, L. G. & Amari, A. “Integrating caregiver report with a systematic choice assessment” (RAISD instrument). American Journal on Mental Retardation, 101, 15–25, 1996.
- Windsor, J., Piché, L. M. & Locke, P. A. “Preference testing: a comparison of two presentation methods”. Research in Developmental Disabilities, 15(6), 439–455, 1994.
- Melanson, I. J., Thomas, A. L., Brodhead, M. T., Sipila-Thomas, E. S., Miranda, D. R. G., Plavnick, J. B., Joy, T. A., Fisher, M. H. & White-Cascarilla, A. N. “An evaluation of preference stability within MSWO preference assessments for children with autism”. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 56(3), 638–655, 2023.
- Hagopian, L. P., Long, E. S. & Rush, K. S. “Preference assessment procedures for individuals with developmental disabilities”. Behavior Modification, 28(5), 668–677, 2004.
This entry is educational and does not replace assessment, diagnosis or treatment by a qualified health professional. Every person is unique — for a specific case, seek individual guidance.