Translated from the Portuguese original. Read the original (Português)
Emotion regulation is the ability to influence which emotions we feel, when we feel them, and how we express them. Many autistic people describe more intense emotions that are harder to modulate — what the literature calls emotion dysregulation. This is not a lack of feeling, a tantrum, or bad manners: it is the combination of sensory overload, difficulty naming what one feels, and an environment that doesn’t always make room. Regulation is learned, and it is usually learned together with someone else.
Emotion regulation is the set of processes — automatic or deliberate — by which a person influences which emotions they have, when they have them, and how they experience and express them (James Gross’s process model). The reference review on the topic opens by stating that autism is associated with amplified emotional responses and poor emotional control — what is called emotion dysregulation. It is not a diagnostic criterion for ASD in the DSM-5-TR, but it shows up across the board in the clinic and helps explain much of the distress and so-called challenging behaviors (Mazefsky et al., 2013).
Feeling too much, not too little
An old myth says autistic people are “cold” or “emotionless.” It confuses two different things: what tends to vary is the expression of the emotion — how it shows up on the outside — not its presence. A person can be deeply shaken and show it in a way the other person doesn’t recognize — or show nothing on the outside while everything overflows on the inside.
There is also a second, less visible obstacle: to regulate an emotion, one must first notice and name it. The persistent difficulty in identifying and describing one’s own feelings is called alexithymia, and it is much more common among autistic people than in the general population — but it is not universal: many autistic people identify their emotions clearly. When alexithymia is present, the body sounds the alarm (racing heart, tension, heat) before the person can translate that into “I’m angry” or “I’m scared.”
It’s worth keeping the right proportion in mind. A 2024 meta-analysis found higher emotion dysregulation in autistic people than in non-autistic people, with an intermediate effect size; when compared with other clinical groups, the difference was small. Difficulty with regulation is, therefore, a common and important problem in autism — but not exclusive to it (McDonald et al., 2024).
The overload curve
Emotional crises rarely come “out of nowhere.” A teaching model widely used in the clinic helps picture the process as a curve: a period inside the window of tolerance — the range in which the person can think, talk, and adjust —, a buildup of triggers, a tipping point, and only then the peak. It’s worth saying what this image is and isn’t: the term “window of tolerance” comes from the trauma literature (Daniel Siegel), not from an autism research finding. It is a map, not a measurement — but a useful map, because recognizing the signs on the way up is what allows for intervention while there is still room.
Why regulating tends to be harder
There is no single cause. What the literature describes is a stacking of factors, which varies a great deal from person to person:
- Sensory load: noise, light, smell, and texture that go unnoticed for some can be painful for others — and drain energy all day long.
- Alexithymia and interoception: difficulty reading the body’s own signals and naming what they mean.
- Unpredictability: changes of plan without warning remove exactly the support that held the day’s organization together.
- Communication: when asking for a break is hard, the body ends up communicating through other means.
- Executive functions: planning, inhibiting, and switching strategy in the middle of a strong emotion requires resources that are already in use.
- Social masking: the ongoing effort to appear “natural,” which charges its price later — often at home, in the safe place.
- Associated conditions: anxiety, ADHD, pain, and poor sleep lower the tolerance threshold. See co-occurring conditions in autism.
There is also a finding about strategies, and it calls for caution. A small study — 21 cognitively able autistic children and adolescents and 22 non-autistic peers — observed, in the autistic group, less use of reappraisal (reinterpreting the situation) and more use of suppression (holding back the outward expression) (Samson et al., 2015). In the general emotion-regulation literature, suppression tends to come with costs: it changes what others see, but changes little of what is actually felt (Gross, 2015). A single small study doesn’t describe the whole spectrum — but the clue is clinically useful.
Meltdown and shutdown are not tantrums
When the load crosses the limit, the system goes into emergency mode. This shows up in two main forms:
- Meltdown: the overload comes out — crying, screaming, intense movement, sometimes aggression or self-injury.
- Shutdown: the same overload goes inward — speech disappears, the body freezes, the person disconnects from the environment.
The difference from a tantrum is decisive — and it lies in the function, not the appearance. A tantrum is a goal-directed behavior, maintained by its consequence: it stops when the goal is reached or clearly becomes unavailable. A meltdown is an involuntary response to overload: it doesn’t pursue a goal, doesn’t negotiate, and doesn’t stop because someone said “stop.” Since the two can look alike from the outside, what decides is not the onlooker’s impression, but the functional assessment. Treating one as the other is the costliest mistake in this area.
What not to do at the peakTalking a lot, asking questions, lecturing, threatening consequences, holding the person back, or opposing on principle — all of this adds load to a system that has already overflowed. Punishing a meltdown doesn’t teach regulation: the punishment acts on the expression, not on the overload that caused it. Safety first, words later.
The five doors of regulation
Gross’s model organizes regulation into five families of strategies, from the beginning to the end of the emotional process. They apply to anyone — what changes in autism is which doors are more accessible and how much support is needed to use them. Tap the cards:
A reminder about this last door: rocking, spinning objects, repeating sounds or phrases is often an efficient form of self-regulation — stimming tends to be a solution, not a symptom. Blocking this resource because it “draws attention” takes away a tool without offering another. When the behavior is safe, the path is to welcome it; see stereotypies (stimming).
Before, during, and after
Supporting emotion regulation isn’t a trick applied in the moment of crisis — it’s work in three stages. Pick one:
Before — reducing the load and increasing predictability
This is the work that pays off the most: the crisis that doesn’t happen.
- Mapping triggers and early warning signs (together with the person themselves, whenever possible).
- A visible routine, transition warnings, and advance notice of changes.
- Sensory adjustments: headphones, scheduled breaks, a resting corner.
- Teaching and accepting a request for a break — by speech, card, gesture, or alternative communication.
- Sleeping, eating, and resting: the tolerance threshold is physiology, not character.
During — safety, quiet, and presence
At the peak, the goal isn’t to teach anything. It’s to get through with the least harm possible.
- Ensuring physical safety and reducing stimulation: fewer people, less light, less sound.
- Speaking little, with short sentences, and waiting. Repeating questions makes it worse.
- Allowing the person’s own regulation strategy (movement, stimming, leaving the place).
- Staying regulated yourself: the calm of the person accompanying is a key resource at this moment — what is usually called co-regulation.
- After the peak, allowing for recovery time. Returning to demands too soon restarts the curve.
After — building a repertoire in calm moments
New skills are taught when the system is stable, never in the middle of the storm.
- Expanding emotional vocabulary and the reading of the body’s signals.
- Teaching and practicing functional ways to ask for help, a break, or a change — with functional assessment of the behavior before choosing the strategy.
- Rehearsing agreed-upon exit routes for predictable difficult situations.
- Adapted psychotherapy, with visual supports, concreteness, and use of the person’s interests.
- Reviewing the environment: if the crisis repeats at the same place and time, the target for change may not be the person.
What the research is backing upStructured programs for emotional awareness and regulation skills adapted to autism have already been tested in randomized controlled trials. That’s the case of EASE, an intervention based mainly on mindfulness, with cognitive-behavioral elements, created for autistic adolescents and young adults with emotion dysregulation. On the behavioral side, functional communication training — teaching an effective way to ask for what the problem behavior used to achieve — is one of the most studied and replicated interventions since the original work of Carr and Durand (1985), preceded by functional assessment. The goal, in every case, is to expand resources and well-being — never to eliminate who the person is.
Test your understanding
Quick quiz
Three questions to help the concept stick. You’ll see the explanation right away.
Further reading
- Gross, J. J. “Emotion Regulation: Current Status and Future Prospects”. Psychological Inquiry, 2015; 26(1): 1–26.
- Mazefsky, C. A.; Herrington, J.; Siegel, M.; Scarpa, A.; Maddox, B. B.; Scahill, L.; White, S. W. “The Role of Emotion Regulation in Autism Spectrum Disorder”. Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, 2013; 52(7): 679–688.
- McDonald, R. G.; Cargill, M. I.; Khawar, S.; Kang, E. “Emotion dysregulation in autism: A meta-analysis”. Autism, 2024; 28(12): 2986–3001.
- Samson, A. C.; Hardan, A. Y.; Podell, R. W.; Phillips, J. M.; Gross, J. J. “Emotion Regulation in Children and Adolescents With Autism Spectrum Disorder”. Autism Research, 2015; 8(1): 9–18.
- Kinnaird, E.; Stewart, C.; Tchanturia, K. “Investigating alexithymia in autism: A systematic review and meta-analysis”. European Psychiatry, 2019; 55: 80–89.
- White, S. W.; Conner, C. M.; Beck, K. B.; Mazefsky, C. A. “Efficacy of the Emotion Awareness and Skills Enhancement (EASE) Program in Autism: A Randomized Controlled Trial”. Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, 2025.
- Carr, E. G.; Durand, V. M. “Reducing behavior problems through functional communication training”. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 1985; 18(2): 111–126.
- Siegel, D. J. The Developing Mind. Guilford Press, 1999 — origin of the “window of tolerance” concept.
- American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5-TR). 5th ed., text revision, 2022.
- National Autistic Society (United Kingdom). Meltdowns — a guide for all audiences.
- The Open University / OpenLearn. Why an autistic meltdown or shutdown is not a “tantrum”.
This entry is educational and does not replace assessment, diagnosis or treatment by a qualified health professional. Every person is unique — for a specific case, seek individual guidance.