Skip to content
gavelEthics and Supervision

Performance Management (OBM)

When a task doesn’t get done, before talking about lack of willingness it’s worth looking at what the job makes easy and what it makes costly.

Translated from the Portuguese original. Read the original (Português)

boltIn short

Performance management is, in behavior analysis, the use of this science’s principles to improve what people do at work. Instead of asking “why is this person like that?”, it asks what happens before and after the behavior one wants to see more (or less) of. The script is the same: choose an observable target, measure it, find out where the failure is before intervening, give data-based feedback, and reinforce success. It is the branch of behavior analysis applied to organizations, known by the acronym OBM (Organizational Behavior Management) — and, because it touches power relations, it comes with well-defined ethical limits.

Technical definition

Organizational Behavior Management (OBM) is the application of behavior analysis principles to human performance in organizations. The field’s literature usually divides it into two major domains: performance management, aimed at the performance of people and teams, and behavioral systems analysis, aimed at processes and large-scale change. The field has had its own publication since 1977: the Journal of Organizational Behavior Management, whose very first issue already included studies carried out in health and human services.

A note on vocabulary: in human-resources jargon, “performance management” usually names the annual cycle of goal-setting and evaluation. In this entry the term has the technical meaning used in OBM.

The shift that defines the field

Faced with a report that never arrives on time, it is common for the explanation to point inward, at the person: disinterest, disorganization, lack of commitment. Explanations like these have a serious practical problem — nobody knows what to do with them. There is no procedure for “installing commitment.”

Performance management asks a different question. It treats behavior at work like any other operant behavior: something that happens within a three-term contingency — an antecedent that signals the occasion, the response itself, and the consequence that follows and decides whether it will happen again. Changing performance, then, means changing one of these three parts. That is investigable, and it is modifiable.

And there is a detail that is easy to overlook, and that changes everything: consequences do not all carry the same weight. An immediate and certain consequence controls behavior far more than a distant and uncertain one — and almost all of the formal consequences at work (the annual review, the bonus at year’s end, the promotion “someday”) are exactly of the second kind.

At work, behavior has three parts Antecedent the visible checklist Behavior logging the session Consequence what comes after But not every consequence carries the same weight Immediate and certain “the chart goes up right away” strong Distant and uncertain “maybe a bonus at year’s end” weak
Performance management looks at the whole contingency — and takes seriously the fact that, between these two, the one that weighs more is the one that arrives close and for certain.

The work cycle

The expression O.B. Mod. (from organizational behavior modification) comes from the work of Fred Luthans and Robert Kreitner, in the 1970s, and it describes well what the field does in practice, in steps that repeat:

  1. Choose the target. Not “be more proactive,” but something you can see and count: “log the session data before leaving the room.” The target must be observable, measurable, and relevant to the outcome — if nobody notices when it doesn’t happen, it was the wrong metric.
  2. Measure the baseline. How much does this happen today, before any change? Without that number, improvement and the impression of improvement remain indistinguishable. It is the same principle behind data recording and collection in the clinic.
  3. Analyze antecedents and consequences. What signals that it’s time to act? What happens afterward — for those who do it and for those who don’t? This is a step that’s easy to skip — and costly to skip.
  4. Intervene. Change what the analysis pointed to: make the antecedent visible, reduce the effort involved, shorten the distance to the consequence, add feedback, reinforce success.
  5. Evaluate and maintain. Compare against the baseline, and then treat maintenance as part of the plan — not as something that “happens by itself” afterward.

Before training, find out what’s missing

When performance fails, a frequent reaction from organizations is to schedule training. Sometimes that’s right. Often it isn’t: the person already knows how to do it, and what’s missing is materials, clarity about when to do it, or some consequence for having done it. Training people who already know how to do the job wastes time and does not change performance, if the failure lies elsewhere.

To avoid this guesswork, the field has developed assessment instruments. One of them, designed for health and human services, is the PDC-HS (Performance Diagnostic Checklist — Human Services, by Carr and colleagues, 2013) — an adaptation of the original PDC, proposed by John Austin in 2000. It has 20 questions, organized into four sections: 13 can be answered through the account of someone who knows the job, and 7 must be answered through direct observation. Each section is a domain. Explore the four:

Training

Has the person already seen someone do it? Have they already practiced with someone observing and correcting them? Can they perform the task right now, if you ask them to? If the answer is no, no incentive will fix it — what’s missing is a repertoire, and the path is training with guided practice (BST, or Behavioral Skills Training, described in the entry on supervision).

Task clarity and cues

Is it stated anywhere exactly what should be done and when? Is there some cue in the environment at the right time — a visible checklist, an alert, the spreadsheet already open? Here the problem isn’t knowing or wanting to: it’s that nothing reminds the person. The solution is an antecedent, not a consequence.

Resources, materials, and processes

Does the necessary material exist, in sufficient quantity and in usable condition? Does the process allow the task to be done in the time available, or does the workflow make success practically impossible? Demanding performance when the system prevents it is not management — it’s transferring to the person a problem that belongs to the organization.

Consequences of performance, effort, and competition

Does something happen after doing it well — does someone notice, comment, record it? And after not doing it? Does the task cost a lot of effort compared to others? Are there competing tasks, easier or more reinforcing, fighting for the same time? This domain is the classic territory of feedback and positive reinforcement.

Assessing first pays off — and there is data on it. In the study that introduced the PDC-HS, eight treatment rooms at a service had been completing cleaning tasks well below what the checklist required, with baselines between 18% and 47%. The assessment pointed to two likely culprits: lack of training on the tasks and lack of performance feedback. The intervention indicated by it — training that described each checklist item, plus the day’s performance posted on a chart — raised task completion in all eight rooms, with final averages between 80% and 100%. In two of those rooms, before that, the team had tried an intervention not indicated by the assessment (making the task clearer and increasing material availability): in both, it was ineffective. Assessing is not bureaucracy — it’s what keeps the effort from being spent in the wrong place.

Feedback and reinforcement: what the evidence shows

Feedback is one of the most studied pieces of the field — and also one of the easiest to do badly. A meta-analysis of 96 applications of performance feedback, drawn from 71 articles published between 1998 and 2018, concluded that feedback is an effective intervention, consistently producing large and very large effects, and that certain characteristics of feedback generate larger effects more reliably — without the study’s summary stating which ones. An earlier review, covering 1985–1998, had already pointed out that feedback does not improve performance uniformly across every situation, and that combining it with other procedures — antecedents and consequences — makes the effects more consistent.

Whatever those characteristics may be, the study’s summary does not list them. What the field’s practice recommends, and what the logic of reinforcement predicts, is feedback that is specific (addressing the behavior, not the person), frequent and close to the action, anchored in data, and accompanied by some consequence for success. A quarterly email with a chart attached is not performance feedback; it is a report.

verified

Money, feedback, and recognition — and the combination of the threeThe meta-analysis by Stajkovic and Luthans (2003), with 72 studies of behavioral management in organizations, found an overall average effect of d = 0.47, which the authors describe as a 16% improvement in performance (with a 63% probability of success). The moderator analysis indicated that money, feedback, and social recognition each had a significant impact on performance — and that, used together, they produced the strongest effect, greater than the sum of the isolated effects.

Where performance management goes wrong

Measuring people’s work and changing the consequences of what they do means tampering with a power relation. That is why the same technology that improves safety in a factory can turn into surveillance, and the same dashboard that helps a team can turn into a humiliating ranking. Four traps worth paying attention to — tap the cards:

None of these traps is a matter of style: they touch explicit ethical standards. The BACB’s Ethics Code for Behavior Analysts, enforceable since January 1, 2022 for those it certifies, requires that assessment come before designing the intervention (standard 2.13); that behavior-change interventions be based on assessment results and prioritize positive-reinforcement procedures (standard 2.14); that clients and other interested parties be involved throughout the entire service relationship, including in choosing goals, assessments, and interventions (standard 2.09); and that restrictive or punishment-based procedures be recommended only after it has been shown that less intrusive means did not achieve the desired result — or when the already-constituted intervention team determines that the risk of harm to the client outweighs the risk of the procedure itself —, always with the required review processes and with effectiveness continuously evaluated and documented (standard 2.15).

warning

In Brazil, this is part of the profession’s code of ethicsBrazil’s Código de Ética Profissional do Psicólogo (Code of Professional Ethics for Psychologists, CFP Resolution No. 010/05) states, in Fundamental Principle VII, that the psychologist “will consider the power relations in the contexts where they work and the impacts of those relations on their professional activities, taking a critical stance in line with the other principles of this Code.” And Article 2 forbids practicing or being complicit in acts that constitute “negligence, discrimination, exploitation, violence, cruelty, or oppression” (item a) and using or favoring the use of psychological practices “as instruments of punishment, torture, or any form of violence” (item c). For the psychologist who runs or advises on a performance program, building it on threat is not just a poor technical choice — it contradicts the provisions above and may constitute an ethical violation.

Why this appears in a clinical encyclopedia

It may seem that performance management is an industry topic. It isn’t: since the very first issue of the Journal of Organizational Behavior Management, in 1977, there have been studies in the field carried out in health and human services. In a clinic, a school, or a home-based care service, what decides the outcome for the person being served is not the written plan: it is how much it is actually carried out, by real people, session after session. That is procedural integrity, and procedural integrity is a team-performance problem.

That is why performance management and supervision overlap so much: both observe performance live, measure, give data-based feedback, and reinforce success. The difference is one of scope. Supervision answers for a professional in training and for that professional’s client; performance management looks at the whole — the scale, the workflow, the materials, what the organization makes easy and what it makes costly. When a service lives from “putting out fires,” that is often where the problem lies.

The same yardstick applies here as for any intervention: besides working on the numbers, the program needs to be acceptable and valuable to the people who live inside it — the criterion of social validity.

OBM three-term contingency at work PDC-HS performance feedback behavioral systems analysis

Test your understanding

quiz

Quick quiz

Three questions to reinforce the concept. You see the explanation right away.

Further reading

  1. Stajkovic A. D., Luthans F. “Behavioral Management and Task Performance in Organizations: Conceptual Background, Meta-Analysis, and Test of Alternative Models”. Personnel Psychology, 56(1), 155–194, 2003.
  2. Stajkovic A. D., Luthans F. “A Meta-Analysis of the Effects of Organizational Behavior Modification on Task Performance, 1975–95”. Academy of Management Journal, 40(5), 1122–1149, 1997.
  3. Sleiman A. A., Sigurjonsdottir S., Elnes A., Gage N. A., Gravina N. E. “A Quantitative Review of Performance Feedback in Organizational Settings (1998–2018)”. Journal of Organizational Behavior Management, 40(3–4), 303–332, 2020.
  4. Alvero A. M., Bucklin B. R., Austin J. “An Objective Review of the Effectiveness and Essential Characteristics of Performance Feedback in Organizational Settings (1985–1998)”. Journal of Organizational Behavior Management, 21(1), 3–29, 2001. Preceded by: Balcazar F., Hopkins B. L., Suarez Y. “A Critical, Objective Review of Performance Feedback”. Journal of Organizational Behavior Management, 7(3–4), 65–89, 1985.
  5. Carr J. E., Wilder D. A., Majdalany L., Mathisen D., Strain L. A. “An Assessment-based Solution to a Human-Service Employee Performance Problem: An Initial Evaluation of the Performance Diagnostic Checklist — Human Services”. Behavior Analysis in Practice, 6(1), 16–32, 2013. The original instrument: Austin J. “Performance analysis and performance diagnostics”, in Austin J., Carr J. E. (eds.), Handbook of Applied Behavior Analysis, Context Press, 2000, p. 321–349.
  6. Gravina N., Villacorta J., Albert K., Clark R., Curry S., Wilder D. “A Literature Review of Organizational Behavior Management Interventions in Human Service Settings from 1990 to 2016”. Journal of Organizational Behavior Management, 38(2–3), 191–224, 2018.
  7. Luthans F. Organizational Behavior Modification. Scott, Foresman, 1975; and Luthans F., Kreitner R. Organizational Behavior Modification and Beyond. Scott, Foresman, 1984.
  8. Cooper J. O., Heron T. E., Heward W. L. Applied Behavior Analysis. 3rd ed. Pearson, 2020.
  9. Behavior Analyst Certification Board (BACB). Ethics Code for Behavior Analysts, 2020 (in effect since January 1, 2022; updated 08/2024) — standards 2.09, 2.13, 2.14, and 2.15.
  10. Conselho Federal de Psicologia (CFP) (Brazil's Federal Council of Psychology). Código de Ética Profissional do Psicólogo, Resolução CFP nº 010/05.
info

This entry is educational and does not replace assessment, diagnosis or treatment by a qualified health professional. Every person is unique — for a specific case, seek individual guidance.

Looking for professional guidance?

Instituto Walden4 is a psychology and education center in Brasília, Brazil, offering evidence-based assessment and care for autism, psychotherapy and development — in person and online. Our team serves in Portuguese; get in touch and we will find the best way to help.

chat Message us on WhatsApp
chat

Conta Walden4

Entrar

Use o e-mail e a senha da sua conta.